[QE-users] Prussian blue analogue slab cannot converge

LEUNG Clarence liangxy123 at hotmail.com
Sat Sep 26 12:09:06 CEST 2020


Dear QE users,

When I run vc-relax of Prussian blue analogue unitcell, it can converge very well and get good lattice parameter close to experiment.

However, when I run 001 slab with the same computational setting, it can not converge and the estimated scf accuracy is more than 500.

The structure of slab and the input file are as follows:
[cid:36fc2216-3a25-4d5e-8f6b-33e97bc71e90][cid:2489ea40-b68f-43a8-9f28-094b93a7be45]

&CONTROL
  nstep = 200 ,
  wf_collect = .true. ,
  verbosity='low',
  max_seconds = 320000 ,
  etot_conv_thr = 3.5D-6 ,
  forc_conv_thr = 4.0D-4 ,
/
&SYSTEM
  ibrav=6,
  celldm(1)=18.9046311775d0, celldm(3)=2.4990253801d0,
  nat=78,
  ntyp=4,
  ecutwfc=75,
  ecutrho=500,
  input_dft='PBE',
  occupations='smearing',
  smearing = 'gaussian' ,
  degauss = 0.01 ,
  nspin = 2 ,
  starting_magnetization(1) = 0.5 ,
  vdw_corr = 'DFT-D3' ,
  lda_plus_u = .true. ,
  Hubbard_U(2) = 6.0 ,
  Hubbard_U(4) = 4.0 ,
/
&ELECTRONS
  conv_thr=1d-06,
  mixing_beta=0.3d0,
  mixing_mode ='local-TF',
  electron_maxstep = 200 ,
  scf_must_converge = .false. ,
/
ATOMIC_SPECIES
  C 12.010700d0 C.pbe-n-kjpaw_psl.1.0.0.UPF
  Fe 55.845000d0 Fe.pbe-spn-kjpaw_psl.1.0.0.UPF
  N 14.006700d0 N.pbe-n-kjpaw_psl.0.1.UPF
  Ni 58.693400d0 Ni.pbe-spn-kjpaw_psl.1.0.0.UPF
K_POINTS {automatic}
  1 1 1 0 0 0
ATOMIC_POSITIONS {crystal}
   N   0.3044384514d0   0.0008445405d0   0.1997401336d0 0 0 0
   N   0.4991552556d0   0.1955612427d0   0.1997401336d0 0 0 0
   N   0.0008445405d0   0.3044384514d0   0.1997401336d0 0 0 0
   N   0.1955612427d0   0.4991552556d0   0.1997401336d0 0 0 0
   C   0.1883763778d0   0.0005237722d0   0.1998684910d0 0 0 0
   C   0.0005237722d0   0.1883763778d0   0.1998684910d0 0 0 0
   C   0.4994760240d0   0.3116234184d0   0.1998684910d0 0 0 0
   C   0.3116234184d0   0.4994760240d0   0.1998684910d0 0 0 0
  Ni   0.0000000000d0   0.0000000000d0   0.2000780816d0 0 0 0
  Fe   0.4999997961d0   0.0000000000d0   0.2000780816d0 0 0 0
  Fe   0.0000000000d0   0.4999997961d0   0.2000780816d0 0 0 0
  Ni   0.4999997961d0   0.4999997961d0   0.2000780816d0 0 0 0
   C   0.6883765817d0   0.5005235682d0   0.2002876721d0 0 0 0
   C   0.5005235682d0   0.6883765817d0   0.2002876721d0 0 0 0
   C   0.9994761259d0   0.8116235203d0   0.2002876721d0 0 0 0
   C   0.8116235203d0   0.9994761259d0   0.2002876721d0 0 0 0
   N   0.8044386554d0   0.5008443366d0   0.2004160295d0 0 0 0
   N   0.9991553575d0   0.6955614466d0   0.2004160295d0 0 0 0
   N   0.5008443366d0   0.8044386554d0   0.2004160295d0 0 0 0
   N   0.6955614466d0   0.9991553575d0   0.2004160295d0 0 0 0
   C   0.5005235682d0   0.5005235682d0   0.2754580194d0
   C   0.9994761259d0   0.9994761259d0   0.2754580194d0
   N   0.9991553575d0   0.5008443366d0   0.2783331270d0
   N   0.5008443366d0   0.9991553575d0   0.2783331270d0
  Ni   0.7500001020d0   0.7500001020d0   0.3001170408d0
   N   0.5008443366d0   0.5008443366d0   0.3219009954d0
   N   0.9991553575d0   0.9991553575d0   0.3219009954d0
   C   0.9994761259d0   0.5005235682d0   0.3247760622d0
   C   0.5005235682d0   0.9994761259d0   0.3247760622d0
   N   0.6955614466d0   0.5008443366d0   0.3998180521d0
   N   0.5008443366d0   0.6955614466d0   0.3998180521d0
   N   0.9991553575d0   0.8044386554d0   0.3998180521d0
   N   0.8044386554d0   0.9991553575d0   0.3998180521d0
   C   0.8116235203d0   0.5005235682d0   0.3999464094d0
   C   0.9994761259d0   0.6883765817d0   0.3999464094d0
   C   0.5005235682d0   0.8116235203d0   0.3999464094d0
   C   0.6883765817d0   0.9994761259d0   0.3999464094d0
  Fe   0.0000000000d0   0.0000000000d0   0.4001560000d0
  Ni   0.4999997961d0   0.0000000000d0   0.4001560000d0
  Ni   0.0000000000d0   0.4999997961d0   0.4001560000d0
  Fe   0.4999997961d0   0.4999997961d0   0.4001560000d0
   C   0.3116234184d0   0.0005237722d0   0.4003656314d0
   C   0.4994760240d0   0.1883763778d0   0.4003656314d0
   C   0.0005237722d0   0.3116234184d0   0.4003656314d0
   C   0.1883763778d0   0.4994760240d0   0.4003656314d0
   N   0.1955612427d0   0.0008445405d0   0.4004939888d0
   N   0.0008445405d0   0.1955612427d0   0.4004939888d0
   N   0.4991552556d0   0.3044384514d0   0.4004939888d0
   N   0.3044384514d0   0.4991552556d0   0.4004939888d0
   C   0.4994760240d0   0.0005237722d0   0.4755359786d0
   C   0.0005237722d0   0.4994760240d0   0.4755359786d0
   N   0.0008445405d0   0.0008445405d0   0.4784110454d0
   N   0.4991552556d0   0.4991552556d0   0.4784110454d0
  Ni   0.2499998981d0   0.2499998981d0   0.5001949592d0
   N   0.4991552556d0   0.0008445405d0   0.5219789138d0
   N   0.0008445405d0   0.4991552556d0   0.5219789138d0
   C   0.0005237722d0   0.0005237722d0   0.5248539806d0
   C   0.4994760240d0   0.4994760240d0   0.5248539806d0
   N   0.3044384514d0   0.0008445405d0   0.5998961336d0
   N   0.4991552556d0   0.1955612427d0   0.5998961336d0
   N   0.0008445405d0   0.3044384514d0   0.5998961336d0
   N   0.1955612427d0   0.4991552556d0   0.5998961336d0
   C   0.1883763778d0   0.0005237722d0   0.6000244910d0
   C   0.0005237722d0   0.1883763778d0   0.6000244910d0
   C   0.4994760240d0   0.3116234184d0   0.6000244910d0
   C   0.3116234184d0   0.4994760240d0   0.6000244910d0
  Ni   0.0000000000d0   0.0000000000d0   0.6002340816d0
  Fe   0.4999997961d0   0.0000000000d0   0.6002340816d0
  Fe   0.0000000000d0   0.4999997961d0   0.6002340816d0
  Ni   0.4999997961d0   0.4999997961d0   0.6002340816d0
   C   0.6883765817d0   0.5005235682d0   0.6004436721d0
   C   0.5005235682d0   0.6883765817d0   0.6004436721d0
   C   0.9994761259d0   0.8116235203d0   0.6004436721d0
   C   0.8116235203d0   0.9994761259d0   0.6004436721d0
   N   0.8044386554d0   0.5008443366d0   0.6005720295d0
   N   0.9991553575d0   0.6955614466d0   0.6005720295d0
   N   0.5008443366d0   0.8044386554d0   0.6005720295d0
   N   0.6955614466d0   0.9991553575d0   0.6005720295d0


Many thanks,
LIANG Xiongyi
City University of Hong Kong


-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.quantum-espresso.org/pipermail/users/attachments/20200926/d07f9c10/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image.png
Type: image/png
Size: 62553 bytes
Desc: image.png
URL: <http://lists.quantum-espresso.org/pipermail/users/attachments/20200926/d07f9c10/attachment.png>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image.png
Type: image/png
Size: 33449 bytes
Desc: image.png
URL: <http://lists.quantum-espresso.org/pipermail/users/attachments/20200926/d07f9c10/attachment-0001.png>


More information about the users mailing list